How James Talarico Outwitted Ken Paxton

Notes to Young Leaders | 9 November 2026

A note to young leaders.

When you’re unfairly accused, choose wit over indignation.

A month ago, James Talarico, the Democratic candidate for the US Senate in Texas, came down with the flu and went to bed. His reasoning was sound – that if he passed it on to somebody’s grandmother or baby, he couldn’t live with himself.

But in the closing weeks of a Senate race, staying home is close to a revolutionary act. Candidates are expected to shake every hand and kiss every baby in the state, spreading goodwill and whatever else they happen to be carrying.

His Republican opponent, Ken Paxton, saw an opening. At a rally in San Antonio, Paxton began with: “Where do you think they hid that little socialist?” He then led the crowd in a chant of “Where is James Talarico?”

The Paxton campaign kept up the attacks with real dedication. It launched a daily “Where’s Jimmy?” countdown. It put out missing-person posters and issued a formal demand for “proof of life”. Proof of life is a term used in kidnap negotiations, and the campaign helpfully suggested the usual method – a dated newspaper held up to the camera.

When none of this produced the man, it opened a toll-free tip line and announced: “Now we’re asking every Texan to help bring Jimmy home.”

When Talarico eventually got back on his feet almost two weeks later, he spent no time explaining where he had been. He didn’t dispute the count of days, or wave a doctor’s certificate.

In a television interview that has since gone viral, Talarico answered Paxton’s demand: “He has asked for proof of life from me. I’m asking for proof of spine from him.”

With a deft change of noun, the search moved from Talarico’s sickbed to Paxton’s empty lectern.

Talarico had been trying to get Paxton onto a debate stage for months. He even offered to debate him on Fox News: “So, if Fox News is where you’ll be most comfortable, I’ll be there.” For a man supposedly in hiding, he was being unusually helpful about arranging an encounter.

Paxton had spent days insisting that his opponent appear in public. Talarico’s improvement was to suggest that they do it together.

Talarico, to be sure, had time to come up with his clever riposte – what the French call l’esprit de l’escalier, “the wit of the staircase.” Convalescence has its compensations.

Even so, Talarico had read the situation perfectly. Indignation invites a reply. Wit ends the conversation.