Churchill, Kennedy, and the Weight of Scrutiny
A note to young leaders.
We all long for our leaders to be perfect. But leaders are human – all too human.
Great leaders are just like us – except perhaps they have a little more courage, a little more discipline, a little more conviction.
But in them too courage still wrestles with vanity, discipline with desire, conviction with contradiction.
Consider two of the 20th Century’s greatest leaders: Churchill and Kennedy.
Winston Churchill’s speeches gave a besieged nation the moral oxygen to keep fighting. His immortal tribute to the Royal Air Force: “Never in the field of human conflict was so much owed by so many to so few” – could just as readily have applied to him. Yet there is enough in the public record to convict Churchill of imperial arrogance, racist beliefs, catastrophic judgment in places like Gallipoli and India, depressive moods and heavy drinking.
John F Kennedy electrified the US Presidency with glamour and gravity: the Peace Corps, the moonshot, the defence of Berlin, the steel of the Cuban Missile Crisis, and the early moral architecture of civil rights. His most famous line: “Ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country” reminded us that citizenship is not a spectator sport. That said, Kennedy’s reckless womanising in office, including with a 19-year-old White House intern, showed appetites and abuses of power sharply at odds with the idealism of his public life.
And yet, we should be slow to vilify or condemn. Famous leaders don’t have more foibles than you and I. They just have more scrutiny, and more enemies.
If we demand perfection from our leaders, we drive them into either hiding or hypocrisy. Neither serves anyone well.
When people pillory their leaders, I often recite these lines of GK Chesterton from The Ballad of the White Horse:
“When all philosophies shall fail / This word alone shall fit / That a sage feels too small for life / And a fool too large for it.”
Folly is not reserved for fools. The wise know this, and weigh the whole, not just the worst.